Oh Judy – now I don’t feel so terrible ABOUT doing the exact same thing…….printing patterns, buying new ones, filling my car and emptying it again…….I even bought needles even though I probably have the ones that I need…….just in case!
After a great deal of anguish……I finally decided on the LINE BREAK SHAWL 
http://www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/line-break
using Swans Island Coral Red merino…..have you ever used this yarn?
http://www.theloopyewe.com/browse/yarn/swans-island/dyers-choice-limited-edition/yf-120-coral-red/
If you went through the same thing selecting your PROJECT 2 then I know that I am in good company!!!
sao in Midlothian, VA